19. June 2025

Astronomers uncover huge, hot filament of missing normal matter Astronomers uncover huge, hot filament of missing normal matter

An analysis by an international team of astronomers, some from the University of Bonn, supports the cosmological standard model

An international team of astronomers led by Leiden University and with involvement from the University of Bonn has investigated a large filament made of hot gas that connects four galaxy clusters and contains what is known as warm–hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). The strand of hot gas stretches for 23 million light-years, is over 10 million degrees Celsius and could be some of the “missing” ordinary matter that has been predicted by the cosmological standard model but not yet shown to actually exist. The team’s findings have now been published in the journal “Astronomy & Astrophysics.”

This simulation of cosmic filaments
This simulation of cosmic filaments - shows the transition from dark matter (bluish-purple shading) to ordinary matter (orangish-red). © Illustration: Illustris Collaboration
Download all images in original size The impression in connection with the service is free, while the image specified author is mentioned.
Please fill out this field using the example format provided in the placeholder.
The phone number will be handled in accordance with GDPR.

The astronomers analysed a filament connecting four clusters of galaxies: A3532 and A3530 on one side and A3528-N and A3528-S on the other side. The clusters are part of the Shapley Supercluster, a large collection of more than 8000 galaxies located about 650 million light-years away from Earth in the constellation of Centaurus.

The analysis reveals that the filament consists mainly of free electrons and protons with a temperature of more than 10 million degrees Celsius. The density is about 10 particles per cubic meter. That is 30 to 40 times the average density of the universe. In total, the filament accounts for 10 times the mass of the Milky Way.

Combining multiple telescope observations

Hot gas in filaments was observed before, but it's the first time that its properties were determined with an accurate spectroscopic analysis, without significant contamination from black holes and galaxies. To pull off the contamination, the research team used an elegant combination of methods. First, with data from optical telescopes, they determined the orientation of the filament in the sky. Then, with the Japanese Suzaku X-ray space telescope, they obtained a spectrum of the whole region. After that, they used data from the European XMM-Newton telescope to model the contaminating black holes and cancel them out. Finally, they could isolate a spectrum of the filament, which they used to determine its density and temperature.

The problem of the “missing” normal matter

Cosmological observations support the standard model that describes the origins and evolution of the Universe, which presupposes that various forms of matter and energy must exist in certain quantities. Two of these—dark matter and dark energy—are yet to be discovered by particle physicists but are crucial to the continued viability of the model. The former is believed to explain the relatively fast rotational velocities of galaxies and the latter the fact that the Universe is expanding at an ever-faster rate. Baryonic matter, which simply means “ordinary” matter such as electrons and protons, constitutes a mere 5 percent of the total. “It’s not only that the physicists of today don’t understand 95 percent of what makes up our Universe, we’re not even in a position yet to say where half of the remaining 5 percent actually is,” explains Dr. Florian Pacaud from the Argelander Institute for Astronomy at the University of Bonn.

Large-scale cosmological simulations have shown that what is missing is the warm, ionized matter known as WHIM. This is found in huge cosmic filaments, elongated strands of gas that link galaxy clusters to one another. Previous studies, several of them spearheaded by the University of Bonn, had only succeeded in proving the existence of a few isolated examples of the densest filaments, because these are brighter and easier to spot. However, these observations had been at odds with the simulations.

"We did not expect that our new method isolated the signal of the missing baryons so effectively," says research lead Konstantinos Migkas, who began his work at the University of Bonn and is now conducting research at Leiden Observatory and the Space Research Organisation Netherlands (SRON) on an Oort Postdoctoral Fellowship. The results of the analysis show that the filament is four times less dense than those discovered previously, making it typical of those predicted by numerical simulations. "We now show that the properties of cosmic filaments agree with the simulations after all. So, it seems the cosmological simulations were right all along. That is a great reward."

According to the team, the research could lead the way for future studies that search similar locations in the universe for filaments and their properties. It allows the researchers to better understand how the largest structures in the universe connect to each other.

This composite image is based on X-ray data from the space telescopes on board JAXA’s Suzaku and the ESA’s XMM-Newton
This composite image is based on X-ray data from the space telescopes on board JAXA’s Suzaku and the ESA’s XMM-Newton - The filament containing the warm-hot interstellar medium (WHIM) appears here as a purple “patchwork quilt” between the two galaxy clusters at the top (yellow dots) and the two at the bottom (yellow and red dots). The gaps in the patchwork indicate places where the X-rays from the black holes outshine the filament. These are removed in order to uncover the filament. © Illustration: ESA/XMM-Newton and ISAS/JAXA. Acknowledgement: Migkas et al. (2025), ATG Europe

Alongside Leiden University and the University of Bonn, the University of Helsinki and Université Paris-Saclay were also involved in the study. Its findings draw on observations from XMM-Newton, a scientific mission by the European Space Agency (ESA) whose instruments and other contributions are being financed directly by ESA member states and the US (NASA), and from the Suzaku satellite launched by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA). The study was funded by Leiden Observatory’s X-Ray Oort Fellowship, the German Aerospace Center (DLR), an EU Horizon 2020 grant, the French National Research Agency (ANR) and the Research Council of Finland (RCF; formerly the Academy of Finland).

K. Migkas, F. Pacaud, T. Tuominen, N. Aghanim: Detection of WHIM emission from a 7.2Mpc long filament in the Shapley supercluster using X-ray spectroscopy. Astronomy & Astrophysics. 19. Juni 2025. DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202554944
https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202554944

Dr. Florian Pacaud
Argelander Institute for Astronomy
University of Bonn
E-Mail: fpacaud@astro.uni-bonn.de

Wird geladen